TIP

Pass notes is a format of satirical, back-and-forth summary writing popularized by The Guardian.

Name. Ariadne.

Occupation, She manages modification files for video games, primarily Bethesda, maybe others in the future. Usually for games that don’t have ThunderStore/Steam Workshop integration.

When did you two meet? Last August.

Appearance? She’s a work in progress.

What’s wrong with MO2? Apart from not running natively on Linux, nothing. I’m just not feeling the spark, the connection between us anymore.

It’s not them, it’s me.

What about the others? There are plenty of fish in the sea.

Not really.

Nexus Mods App was buried alongside Nexus Mod Manager after it was Old Yeller’ed in January, because Nexus decided it would be better off putting manpower towards updating their existing flagship, Vortex.

What’s wrong with Vortex?

Don’t make me laugh.

No, seriously.

Vortex is in a Ship of Theseus situation, where the developers must simultaneously grapple with immense technical debt, confusing design decisions, and mind-boggling UI and also add new features on top at the same time.

It doesn’t run on Linux either, at least not officially.

Oh and don’t forget it has to do that while maintaining support for thousands of games with modding communities big and small, while also keeping Collections intact.

Did I mention two rules for every file conflict between mods, which quickly balloons into a tangled mess of who-wins-who? Todd Forbid you get a cycle, which means you’ve somehow cornered yourself into a circular dependency loop, and presents itself in a diagram of lines that can only be described as the undergraduate thesis of a failed electrical engineer.

Vortex aims to simplify modding so much that I sometimes wonder if they’ve looped back around like their own conflict cycles.

Also, why are my in-progress Downloads placed in the Notifications tray?

And Ariadne can do better?

Well for one, she’s not using Electron. That’s already better in my books. Ariadne also runs on both Windows and Linux natively, so no Wine shenanigans there.

She was formerly written in C# using .NET, but I moved away from that because .NET has so much boilerplate. Dependency injection. Interfaces. Inheritance. Services.

The GUI domain language, XAML, also makes me want to put a gun to my head.

So I’m rcurrently in the process of rewriting her in Rust, using Freya for the GUI.

VFS?

Of course; it’s the gold standard for mod managers.

What makes her special is copy-on-write semantics, which means any time any application (including the game) attempts to write to a game file, it’s gracefully redirected into a copy located in a separate folder of your choosing.

MO2 also has Overwrite, you know.

Similar, but not the same. MO2 can’t detect writes reliably due to its nature of hooking filesystem functions within the application itself. It can only redirect newly created files to Overwrite.

So a non-destructive workflow for immutable installs. Pretty much.

Sounds awfully similar to NMA.

The end goal is the same, yes, but the means are different.

And I won’t lie to you, NMA design documents are solid and the staff at Nexus have obviously put in their blood, sweat, and tears into the project, and you can tell. The problem was the glacial development pace from hand-rolling so many of their solutions, and the constant piling on of ideas that were good in theory, but cost countless late nights in implementation.

It’s like that whole, “meet potential man” meme, but for mod managers.

Exactly.

NMA still has some cool concepts behind it, in particular their use of a Datomic-like model, which makes it trivial to query the database for information from any moment in time, from the very beginning if one desires. This leads to some nice side-effects like near-infinite undo/redo, provided you can reconcile disk state well.

So kudos to the NMA developers for sticking to their guns. Their hand-rolled database is definitely a source of inspiration.

What else is different?

Nothing, really, apart from my own Frankenstein twist on the classic MO2 UI. I’m frankly dreading the UI design more than the actual back-end design.

Do say: “It’s like MO2 and NMA had a baby.”

Don’t say: “Just use Amethyst.”